Skip to content
Home » A Guide to Chicago’s Best Pie Shops

A Guide to Chicago’s Best Pie Shops

Discover Chicago’s best pies! Indulge in sweet and savory treats that tantalize your taste buds. From traditional classics to innovative creations, these pies will satisfy even the pickiest palate.

Explore “The Pie Hole.” Enjoy handcrafted pies made with the finest ingredients. Flaky crusts and generous fillings make each slice a heavenly treat.

Visit “Sweet Morsels Bakery.” Savor unique flavor combinations and stunning presentation. From caramel apple to bacon and maple pecan pies, each bite is a delightful surprise.

For traditional flavors, try “Baker s Delight.” Family-owned recipes have been passed down through generations. Enjoy grandma’s classics like apple pie with a hint of cinnamon or rich chocolate silk.

Creative ideas? Start the day with a warm cup of coffee and key lime pie from “Pie Pantry Cafe.” Feeling adventurous? Try chicken pot pie with fluffy mashed potatoes at “Gourmet Pies.” Comfort food at its finest.

Chicago’s Best Pie Shops

Chicago houses some of the most delightful and scrumptious pie shops! You can satisfy your sweet tooth with a wide array of pies offered. Here is a list of the top-notch establishments and their specialties:

Pie Shop Specialty
Sweet Treats Fruit pies
Flaky Delights Buttery & flaky crusts
Pie Paradise Flavor combos
Heavenly Pies Homemade favorites
Tasty Temptations Unique twists on traditional pies

These pie shops offer delicious treats, inviting ambiance, and exceptional customer service. From classic apple pies to unconventional flavor pairings, they have something for everyone!

Fresh, high-quality ingredients are used to create these delectable bites. Chicago’s best bakeries and pastry shops source these ingredients locally whenever possible!

Heavenly Pies has been around since 1965. Enjoy timeless recipes from over five decades!

Head to the Windy City and indulge in divine creations from these remarkable pie shops. Your taste buds will thank you!

Criteria for Determining the Best Pie Shops

To discover the best pie shops in Chicago, careful evaluation is needed. One must assess quality, taste, and overall experience. To assess these, here are the criteria:

  1. Flavorful Fillings: Richness and depth of flavors should captivate the taste buds.
  2. Perfect Crust: It should be perfectly baked, not overpowering the filling.
  3. Variety of Options: Must have an array of options to cater to different preferences.
  4. Attention to Detail: Every aspect, from presentation to packaging should contribute to an exceptional customer experience.
  5. Exceptional Customer Service: Friendly staff that are knowledgeable about their products.
  6. Overall Experience: Ambiance, seating, and music should all contribute to an enjoyable dining experience.

Other noteworthy details include locally sourced, seasonal ingredients and unique flavors inspired by international cuisines. Don’t miss out! Indulge in the irresistible flavors and exquisite craftsmanship that await you. Uncover the hidden gems and experience why these pie shops have earned their esteemed reputations. Taste the extraordinary and settle for nothing less than perfection!

Top Picks for Chicago’s Best Pie Shops

Chicago is a pie-lover’s paradise! Here are the top picks for the city’s best pie shops. From classic apple to adventurous flavors like key lime or chocolate bourbon pecan, these establishments have something for everyone.

  • 1. Sweet Mandy B’s offers homemade pies with fresh ingredients. Enjoy their flaky crusts and rich fillings!
  • For a sweet treat, check out a guide to Chicago’s best cookie shops for delicious options.
  • 2. Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits is perfect for those craving both sweet and savory. Try their unique creations like caramel apple crumble and chicken pot pie.
  • 3. Hoosier Mama Pie Company caters to traditionalists and innovators alike. With their wide selection of flavors and fillings, you’ll come back for more. If you’re a fan of sweet treats, check out this Chicago cupcake shops guide for more delicious options!
  • 4. The Hidden Pearl Cafe is a cozy gem serving handcrafted pies made from scratch. Indulge in their silky banana cream or tangy lemon meringue.

Plus, there are vegan options at Pie Pie My Darling, late-night cravings at First Slice Pie Cafe, and vintage charm at Spinning J Bakery & Soda Fountain.

Go ahead and explore these top pie shops in Chicago. Savor the flavors, appreciate the craftsmanship, and make unforgettable memories. Your taste buds will thank you – don’t miss out on a single slice of piping hot goodness!

Tips for Finding the Perfect Pie

Trying to find the ideal pie can be a challenge. Here are some helpful tips to make it easier:

  1. Investigate the different pie shops. Maybe one of them specializes in fruit pies, or has a great selection of savoury pies.
  2. Take notice of the crust. It should be flaky and baked to perfection. Check reviews and ask other pie fans for the best places.
  3. Make sure the shop uses fresh ingredients. Quality ingredients will make the pie taste even better!
  4. Don’t forget to look at the atmosphere. Cozy shops with friendly staff make the whole experience more pleasant.

Furthermore, some places have unique flavors that you won’t find anywhere else. It’s worth trying them out!

Lastly, read reviews to get valuable information about the best pie spots in Chicago.

To summarize, when searching for the perfect pie:

  1. Check out a variety of shops
  2. Pay attention to the crust
  3. Choose shops with fresh ingredients
  4. Consider the ambiance

By following these guidelines, you’ll increase your chances of finding the most delicious pies and having an extraordinary experience with every bite!


Chicago’s Best Pie Shops tantalize your taste buds. With a wide selection of pies, each shop offers something special. Whether you like classic flavors or unique combinations, there’s something for everyone.

Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria has deep-dish pies with a buttery crust. Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits has sweet fruit pies and flaky biscuits. Pleasant House Bakery has savory pies, from British-style meat to vegetarian options. Check out this guide to Chicago’s best cake shops for more delectable treats.

Hoosier Mama Pie Company has an array of flavors, from classic apple and cherry to creative ones like bourbon pecan and chocolate chess.

I had a remarkable experience at Spinning J Bakery & Soda Fountain. The comforting atmosphere and the smell of freshly-baked pies pulled me in. I couldn’t help but try their banana cream pie. It was heavenly! Creamy custard, ripe bananas, and a buttery crust – it was perfection!

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What are some of the best pie shops in Chicago?
A: Some of the best pie shops in Chicago include Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits, Hoosier Mama Pie Company, and Bake.

Q: Are these pie shops suitable for vegans and vegetarians?
A: Yes, many of these pie shops offer vegan and vegetarian options. Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits and Pie, Pie My Darling are known for their delicious vegan pies.

Q: Do these pie shops offer gluten-free options?
A: Yes, several of these pie shops offer gluten-free options. Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits and First Slice Pie Caf are known for their gluten-free pies.

Q: Can I order pies online or for delivery?
A: Absolutely! Most of these pie shops offer online ordering and delivery services. You can easily satisfy your pie cravings without leaving your home.

Q: Can I get pies customized for special occasions?
A: Yes, many of these pie shops offer customized pies for special occasions such as birthdays or weddings. Contact the pie shop in advance to discuss your requirements.

Q: Are these pie shops family-friendly?
A: Yes, these pie shops are family-friendly. You can enjoy a slice of pie with your loved ones in a cozy and welcoming atmosphere.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *